luciole (he/him)

Doesn’t know the lyrics. Just goes meow meow meow.

  • 1 Post
  • 107 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 6th, 2023

help-circle



  • Some non peer reviewed paper with a tiny sample size is hardly enough to go “The Science has spoken”. On the other hand, one can make an appeal to the intuitive idea that lack of practice implies lack of skill.

    This immediately points to the pernicious effects of touting LLMs as a machine to do all the thinking for you. Heck, the enthusiasts are even using LLMs to do their social interactions for them.

    This is a warning to people as much as workplaces: is this task you’re offloading to LLMs really a skill you want to see atrophied?












  • Good on you for owning up and best of luck. You did well being transparent about your process. I’m going to add two things about generative AI:

    • Writing is thinking. If you’re interested in thinking, then be all means do it yourself. You don’t need to have perfect grammar, syntax and such. Lots of extraordinary authors don’t. Strive for improvement, don’t worry about perfection.
    • Absolutely beware of generative AI’s biases. They may actually amplify their sources’ biases while occluding them. AI text is just rehashed human text, with all that it entails.

  • I’m not going to read in detail a text you can’t be assed to write in detail. From a glean I’ll say two things:

    • Your alternative voices are basically all privileged white guys commenting carefully from the sidelines. How is that a counterbalance to Chinese activists literally disappearing? You know what it means to disappear in China, right?
    • The common thread of your text is one massive, obvious false dilemma. It’s common knowledge that China is under a repressive regime, that the POTUS gives clear signals of envying such regimes, AND that democracy has issues. We can and do talk about all of them.